Advanced Filters

Page 4 - Small Cap U.S. Insurance Stocks by Market Cap

UPDATED Apr 10, 2026

Discover small cap U.S. Insurance companies that are on the NYSE and NASDAQ. These Insurance Companies are organised by Market Cap.

115 companies
CompanyLast Price7D Return1Y ReturnMarket CapAnalysts TargetValuationGrowthDiv Yield
SIGI
US$79.943.9%-7.7%US$4.9bUS$87.2910.58.2%2.2%
MCY
US$92.214.5%77.9%US$5.2bUS$110.009.4-9.9%1.4%
RLI
US$58.00-0.2%-24.2%US$5.4bUS$58.0013.2-11.7%4.6%
WTM
US$2,301.146.1%32.5%US$5.6bn/a5.2n/a0.04%
THG
US$176.780.4%13.2%US$6.3bUS$198.009.4-0.5%2.1%
FAF
US$63.318.7%6.5%US$6.5bUS$82.0010.45.1%3.5%
LNC
US$34.20-1.9%15.9%US$6.6bUS$43.506.013.1%5.3%
AXS
US$98.14-3.5%5.6%US$7.6bUS$123.367.44.8%1.8%
PRI
US$261.222.9%3.7%US$8.3bUS$294.0011.03.0%1.8%
KNSL
US$348.311.0%-27.8%US$8.4bUS$377.1116.01.1%0.3%
RYAN
US$34.573.2%-52.5%US$9.2bUS$49.6570.248.5%1.5%
ORI
US$40.861.2%10.3%US$10.0bUS$42.5010.5-5.0%9.0%
AFG
US$130.690.8%4.0%US$11.0bUS$140.5012.97.6%2.7%
AIZ
US$219.400.5%15.7%US$11.1bUS$260.0012.610.7%1.6%
GL
US$145.842.3%22.0%US$11.6bUS$171.099.93.9%0.7%
UNM
US$76.673.4%1.9%US$12.5bUS$93.6217.016.2%2.4%
CNA
US$47.222.1%-0.6%US$12.9bUS$43.0010.0n/a8.3%
FNF
US$47.433.8%-20.9%US$13.0bUS$64.6021.431.0%4.4%
RNR
US$303.030.9%27.3%US$13.4bUS$329.275.0-16.8%0.5%
ERIE
US$253.761.7%-39.5%US$13.5bn/a23.7n/a2.3%
EG
US$329.870.8%-5.6%US$13.6bUS$362.738.513.8%2.4%
RGA
US$205.05-0.05%15.1%US$13.7bUS$248.7811.414.2%1.8%
BNT
US$42.741.8%31.8%US$14.3bn/a18.6n/a0.7%
PFG
US$91.801.9%26.4%US$20.0bUS$94.1716.815.8%3.4%
Page 4 of 5